Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Shocking Stem Cell Therapy Story.

There is a terrible story in the news today in England, about a doctor who was exploiting MS patients with promises of a cure by undergoing expensive stem cell treatment.

Shocking to hear this story and only confirms for me yet again that there are too many who seek to exploit vulnerable people with degenerative diseases like MS.

Having MS which has no cure and where only disease modifying drugs are available makes us all very open to exploitation by unscrupulous people.

Who want to make a profit at the expense of exploiting people’s fears and desires to find a cure for their MS.

We are all vulnerable to people like that with promises of cures and who would not want to be cured of MS.

I know that I would love nothing more than being cure of my Primary Progressive MS, would love to be able to move my body again.

To go for a walk with my darling Richie and go once again to visit all our favourite places in the city.

Would be wonderful to be able to walk, to go to the toilet and shower independently, to do all the things that I took for granted until I could no longer do them.

As I have found out once my MS progressed so fast there was barely time to register what was happening before something else happened.

After my diagnosis in 2006 I went online to find information about MS and also found many offers of cures, which I knew were not based in reality.

They all seemed to be about tapping in to the fears and exploiting the vulnerabilities of people with an incurable disease like MS.

That is why the story about the unscrupulous doctor was so shocking to hear about on the radio today.

The idea that a doctor should be exploiting people in this way is very worrying and has really shocked me tremendously.

From BBC Website 29 September

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-11425435


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/newsnight/9040456.stm

Stem cell doctor Robert Trossel struck off by GMC



Dr Robert Trossel had consulting rooms in London and Rotterdam

A doctor who offered unlicensed stem cell treatments to patients with MS has been struck off by the General Medical Council.

Dr Robert Trossel treated several men and women, who paid around £10,000.

The GMC found that the doctor, who trained in the Netherlands, had breached good medical practice by "exploiting vulnerable patients".

Dr Trossel, 56, who worked in London and Rotterdam, conceded he had been "too enthusiastic" about the treatment.

At an earlier hearing, the GMC Fitness to Practise panel said that Dr Trossel had exaggerated the benefits of treatment based on "anecdotal and aspirational information".

 His patients, who had an aggressive and disabling type of multiple sclerosis, paid up to £10,000 or more for stem cell injections, with some raising the money through charity events.

However, the stem cells offered were not intended for human use, only for laboratory research.

Tom Kark QC, for the GMC, spoke of the patients' "anger and sense of being let down".

"They were all vulnerable patients who already found themselves failed by the medical profession in this country and as a result were searching, some with desperation, for a cure or relief elsewhere, which is why and how they ended up in Dr Trossel's hands," Mr Kark told the GMC.

"They were given false hope by him and the experience not only cost them financially but for the most part it caused them personal and emotional loss when they realised that the treatment provided to them was not only expensive but pointless."

The treatment also contained bovine brain and spinal cord, and the GMC panel ruled he had abused his position as a doctor by failing to warn patients about potential risks of vCJD.

The doctor's own lawyer had told the hearing how patients were informed about the experimental nature of the injections, and that he had stopped using them when the nature of the stem cells became clear following a BBC Newsnight investigation.

He said that the doctor was "compassionate", and had not acted dishonestly.

Despite Dr Trossel's apparent "change of heart", panel chairman Professor Brian Gomes da Costa said he had shown "little insight" into the seriousness of what he had done, and how it might have affected his patients.

Patient fears

The GMC heard that the patients involved had yet to be refunded the thousands of pounds they paid for their treatment.

Karen Galley, 45, from Essex, visited Dr Trossel's clinic in August 2006, and was charged around £10,500 for the treatment, receiving one injection in the arm and six in the neck.

‘’ It makes me feel sick that somebody could exploit vulnerable people in this way”

 Karen Galley Patient of Dr Trossel

Friends and colleagues of Ms Galley had helped her raise the money, with one running a mini-marathon and another undertaking a sponsored diet.

She said she was "angry and scared" after finding out that the injections contained bovine spinal tissue.

"His QC has described him as a compassionate doctor - but that is rubbish, no compassionate person treats people like that."

She said that she now lived in fear of diseases such as vCJD, for which there is no test or treatment.

She said: "It makes me feel sick that somebody could exploit vulnerable people in this way."

Another MS patient, accountant Malcolm Pear, from Bromsgrove in Worcestershire, visited the Rotterdam clinic in January 2006.

After paying £8,000, the treatment was delivered in a "coffee lounge" rather than a private treatment room.

"I suppose alarm bells should have started ringing then," said his wife Lesley.

She said they were led to believe that the treatment was composed simply of umbilical cells, but found out later that bovine tissue was involved.

After a fleeting improvement, Mr Pear's condition has now deteriorated significantly.

Mrs Pear said: "When you are sitting in front of a neurologist who is saying 'look, there is nothing you can do', you clutch at straws."

"I am not saying we are the most intelligent people on God's Earth, but we certainly are not completely stupid."

After the verdict, Dr Trossel said he was "disappointed".

He added: "I would like to take the opportunity to say how sorry I am for any distress caused to my patients during this time.

"During my career as a doctor, I have always practised with the objective of achieving the very best for my patients."

‘’ You have exploited vulnerable patients and their families...Your conduct has unquestionably done lasting harm, if not physically, then mentally and financially, to these patients and also to their families and supporters. ‘’

Brian Gomes da Costa of the General Medical Council


http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/ms-treatments-doctor-should-be-struck-off-2090928.html

http://news.uk.msn.com/articles.aspx?cp-documentid=154802839

http://www.birminghampost.net/news/west-midlands-news/2010/09/29/stem-cell-treatment-doctor-struck-off-by-gmc-65233-27368125/

http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2010/sep/10/doctor-exploited-patients-stem-cell

http://www.hospitaldr.co.uk/blogs/web-news/stem-cell-doctor-struck-off-by-gmc

5 comments:

Karen said...

Hi Herrad,
We hear of this kind of thing a lot in Canada. It doesn't happen here, but many people go to South America or Mexico to have this type of treatment done.

Unfortunately unscrupulous people come in walks of life...doctors, lawyers, politicians, police, and so on and so on.

It doesn't shock me any more, but still makes me sick.

Cheers,
Karen

Herrad said...

Hi Karen,
You are right of course there are plenty of unscrupulous people of all professions and types.
Just got to me today that a doctor would this.
Thanks for coming by today.
Love,
Herrad

ρομπερτ said...

Surreal, and difficult to understand indeed; agree with the voice above, able to be believed.

Please have you all a good Friday.

daily athens

Missie said...

I think I'm caught up on your blog now. I'm so behind with the blogs that I read regulary.

Have a good week.

Herrad said...

Hi Robert,
You are right it is difficult to understand how a doctor could do such a thing, but I guess they are just people.
Have a good Friday too.

Hi Missie,
Good to see you comment, thanks for coming by.
Hope your week has been good.

Thanks you two dear people for coming by and commenting.
Good to see your comments.
Love,
Herrad